Discussion about this post

User's avatar
Glenn McNair's avatar

As a college professor at an elite school, I can assure you that the indoctrination is real and ongoing. My students know all of the slogans and theories, and yet when quizzed about them rarely can they explain what they are asserting, beyond citing racial disparities. For example, this week I was explaining why redlining did not play the role in the Black-White wealth gap that students assume. Before beginning, I asked how many of them thought the claim was true. All of them did. I then asked what redlining was. Only one student could offer a half coherent explantation. For most, it apparently had something to do with maps that lowered housing values. One student—a very smart one—said that it was the process of forcibly relocating Black people to the undesirable parts of cities.

Thankfully, once I start to unpack historical reality students are quite open to what I have to say; indeed, many seek out my classes because they know they will get heterodox perspectives. I take this approach in my teaching because I believe that my first responsibility is to truth, but more importantly, because I was indoctrinated as an HBCU undergrad. Republicans/conservatives were racist. That's it. I was disabused of this notion—embarrassingly—in law school. My best friend was a White guy from NYC. We did everything together, and I could say then and now that there wasn't a racist bone in his body. One day we were just talking and he said he was a conservative Republican. I was literally stunned because that was simply impossible. He had to be joking. He then began to school me on conservatism in the Western political tradition, from Edmund Burke to F.A. Hayek. I had never heard of ANY of these people—and I had taken many political science and history courses. I felt like a fool and wanted to call him a racist and hide under the bed, but I couldn't because he wasn't. I was angry and felt that I had been cheated and betrayed, indoctrinated rather than educated, taught what to think rather than how to think. From that day forward (long before the idea of being a professor popped into my head) I committed myself to resisting totalizing ideologies and to put in the extra work to think through issues and arrive at my own conclusions, wherever on the ideological spectrum they might be found.

I am always amazed that so many of my colleagues can be intellectually satisfied by finding ever more sophisticated ways of proving that Blacks people are oppressed. I would be bored out of my mind had I spent a quarter century reinforcing a social construct (race) and a fixed binary while trying to convince myself that I was doing nothing of the sort. Young people are ready for the truth; they are ready to be challenged. It is we adults who have failed them, not the other way around.

David Bethea's avatar

Beautiful Easter message. Thank you and God bless.

11 more comments...

No posts

Ready for more?