Discussion about this post

User's avatar
Charles Ekokotu's avatar

Thank you for this article, it's an interesting read, but I have an issue with a certain narrative that is common amongst African writers who write about Africa to a predominantly western audience and I fear that African affairs are being coloured in the light of American culture war narratives of victim Vs victor, racism etc. an example of this can be found in a point you made which I'll quote below

"As I say in the video below, if you line up 100 Africans on one side and 100 non-Africans on the other, and you ask them, Why is Africa poor?, most Africans (and their allies) will come up with the usual suspects: colonialism, slavery, they’re stealing our natural resources, racism, yada yada yada yada."

The point you made above is so painfully wrong and unimformed that I'm astonished that you would make such a point. If you indeed lined up 100 Africans, colonialism and slavery, would not be in the top 5 reasons, that's if they're mentioned at all. Racism will not even be mentioned. Africans are more likely to blame corruption, bad government, mismanagement and a host of other things you mentioned rather than mentioning colonialism and slavery or racism.

Africans are so past these things that they exhibit a snubbish attitude towards African Americans when they emigrate to the west when things like slavery and racism are mentioned as holding Black people back.

So, why would you write something that's obviously incorrect? I have seen this trend amongst many Black writers writing for a western audience. This narrative of looking at African affairs through a western culture war narrative paints a false picture.

You're more likely to hear complaints like the one you mentioned from Africans living in the diaspora rather than those on the continent, that's because they have also imbibed western culture war narratives as causative factors. Most Africans aren't worried about racism not in the least.

Lastly to answer the question, why is Africa poor, it's due to varied number of factors and yes that includes the ones you mentioned such as corruption, bribery, etc, just as much as it includes the ones you're disputing such as colonialism/neocolonialism, resource exploitation, predatory loans and the setup of the global economy which favours the global North at the expense of the global South, while the points you mentioned are much more obvious, the points you're disagreeing with are much more sinister because there is a tendency to ignore them and paint whoever raises them up as playing the victim, many things can be right at the same time.

Thank you

Wen Jin's avatar

Wow, what an interesting point of view! I never put corruption in the context of economic unfreedom, but it absolutely makes sense! It was (is) the same in Communist countries, some of the poorest and more corrupt places on earth, and not for lack of resources. Thank you for this article!

17 more comments...

No posts

Ready for more?